Well we are testing Premiere Pro CS 5.5 for a few weeks now. Yes, we tried that in the past and it did not work out well. But with the release of the 9.2 Version of the Blackmagic Design drivers (Blackmagic Design Desktop Video 9.2 - a while ago now) for the BMD Video-Cards we use something changed and now it actually works quite well.
Now, we still use FCP7 for older or “special” projects. But with CS6 in the very near future things are looking good … well bad for FCP and Apple. The whole AVID MC 6 thing did not work that good for the stuff we do… even though it’s a great NLE … it’s just not for how we things rock over here, lets just leave it at that. I will not talk about FCPX … u know how I feel about it … for some work its great …for most stuff not tho’ (a matter of “taste” anyway) … it will take a loooooooong time till that App will be 100% ready … end of story (for FCPX).
Anyway… here are some settings that worked quite well for us and our “old” MacPro’s with Blackmagic Cards. One note: We are in PAL-Land so we work with 1080p25 or 50i … u might try other frame rates for your footage!
BTW we are on “older” MacPros with 12 GB Ram, MacOS 10.6.8 and BlackMagic Design Decklink HD Extreme 2 cards. (We did not test this in LION / 10.7.x)
All starts with a “New Project” … select “Blackmagic Capture” … just to be safe. ( at this point I’m not 100% sure if that is Essential or not)… and choose a project name and make sure you did choose a (the right) project folder / location …
You might choose your Video “Settings” … (that is for capture only… if u want to do that)
Now comes the essential part: After you hit OK … You have to choose the Blackmagic Design HD1080 preset (8 bit or 10 bit with the Frame-rate your footage is in) Don’t use the DSLR Preset, that doesn’t work well at all for most Machines (using ProRes footage / with external Playback) One side-note if you use an external Monitor (via HDMI for example) that can not play/show progressive footage (25p in our case) you have to choose an Interlaced Preset (50i in our case) … you will be able to work with progressive footage (25p in our case) just as good in that Interlaced Timeline it will NOT change it to interlaced or something …. at least in our case.